top of page

Colonel E.H. Taylor Small Batch Bourbon Review

Updated: Dec 31, 2022

I tasted this alongside an Heaven Hill BiB 7 year as a bit of a bottled in bond battle. I had tasted the E.H. Taylor many more times before the Heaven Hill offering. I will include a note on my preference between the two after the rating. See the Heaven Hill review here.


Company on Label: Old Fashioned Copper (Buffalo Trace)

Whiskey Type: Bourbon

Mash Bill Percentages: Buffalo Trace Mash Bill #1 (Low Rye < 10%)

Proof: 100°

Age: 4 years

Further identification: Late 2019 purchase


Nose: Chocolate & molasses. Brown sugar that layers into a sweet silky cherry. Slight spice when you dig through the caramel. Light cinnamon that isn't biting. Vanilla here is sweet... cake or dessert-like. An orange zest and slight tannin forming later in the nose. After sipping, some light oak can be found. No ethanol to be found here, deep inhales are exceptionally sweet & satisfying. The chocolate & molasses sweetness is indomitable.

Palate: Mmm. Explosive candy sweets. Sugary molasses melts into liquid strawberry, apple and cherry. Drinks in a wave from front to back, and lingers most near the very back of the tongue. Some pepper and a hint of deep, dark red grape. A touch of citrus gives this a complexity that turns this from a candy novelty to an exceptional (relatively) accessible sipper.


Rating: 4/5

Due to the lower age producing a more explosive and complex experience I have to give a nod to the @buffalotrace offering over the Heaven Hill tonight. Both pours were thoroughly enjoyable and I would recommend having each on your shelf.



bottom of page